How much does it cost to fix a BMW 1 Series differential?

Despite being BMW’s smallest car, the 1 Series still comes with all the refinement and quality of the larger models, but does it also come with the potential for high repair costs?

The differential is a key component in your car's drivetrain, so how much is a 1 series differential likely to cost to repair?

How much does it cost to replace a BMW 1 Series differential?

The average cost to replace a BMW 1 Series differential is between £300 and £2,500, depending on the model and whether new or used parts are used. 

A brand new differential from BMW can easily set you back £2,000 plus fitting, which will typically cost between £150 and 300 depending on the garage’s hourly rates. 

A slightly cheaper option is to get a refurbished unit, costing between £450 and £1,200 on average. These are made using original BMW differential casings, but with refreshed seals, bearings and sometimes gears. 

The cheapest option is to fit a differential from a breaker or dismantler for around £140-350. These are units removed from scrapped cars. In many cases, these will be untested and without any guarantee. 

Have your car repaired by one of our approved garages. Split the cost with interest-free car repair finance.

What is a differential?

When a car turns, the wheels on the outside of the car (right wheels during a left-hand turn, and vice versa) have to turn at a higher rate than the ones on the inside. For driven wheels that are linked to each other via driveshafts, this presents an issue. 

A differential is used to allow power to be transmitted to both wheels, even when one needs to spin faster than the other. All internal combustion engine cars made in the last 120 years or so have a differential; certain cars, such as 4WD ones, have more than one.

How do differentials break?

Like all mechanical components, normal use causes wear, not just between the gears inside the differential, but also to the oil seals and bearings present too.

Wear can be accelerated by poor maintenance or a lack of lubrication. The latter is often caused by oil seals becoming dry and ineffective, allowing oil to leak out over time. Something that regular checkups and maintenance can help.

In most BMW cars, being Rear Wheel Drive, the issue can be exacerbated by the fact that the differential sits separately from the gearbox and engine, at the rear of the car. This makes oil leaks easier to miss.

Can you repair a differential?

Yes, many differential issues can be repaired without needing to replace the whole unit. Problems such as:

• Damaged input shaft seals
• Damaged output shaft seals
• Replacing certain bearings
• Replacing differential mountings

However, if the problem is more serious, such as the internal gears being excessively worn, or the unit needs specialised tools to work on it, many garages will only offer replacement as an option.

How to tell if your differential is broken

Common symptoms of a worn differential include:

• Whirring or droning noise from the rear of the car
• A clunk or jolt when accelerating or letting off the accelerator
• Oil leaks from the rear of the car, directly between the rear wheels
• Grinding, or vibration, when taking tight turns

Can you drive with a broken differential?

No, as the differential is directly linked to the rear wheels, regardless of whether the car is in neutral, a serious failure inside, such as a bearing collapsing, could cause the rear wheels to suddenly lock up at speed.

What’s more, a differential with a minor oil leak, or grumbling bearing, can often be repaired at a relatively low cost. However, continuing to drive the car could result in a very large bill, should irreparable damage be caused. 

Have your BMW differential repaired through Bumper

Looking to have your BMW differential repaired? Split the cost with Bumper's car repair loans at thousands of approved garages across the country.

Author - Joseph Law

Joseph has been writing about cars for over eight years and writing for Bumper for over three, blending his passion for automobiles with a talent for storytelling.

Joseph has written about engineering and cars for Autozilla, Komaspec, and several engineering manufacturers. When he's not writing or tinkering with one of his cars, Joseph dreams of owning an Alfa Romeo 33 Stradale.